Alonzo Mosely

Bingowings said:

I repeat my suggestion that some physical effects be added to the pre-shook footage to make the shake feel more real.

If Ady can build a flap to match the model to the back view out of the snowspeeder window, building a wall locker door to shake open or some minor objects to fly off surfaces are doables.

 I agree with this.

Hello everyone, I have been following this project since ANH:R and haven't felt the need to switch from lurker to poster until now. With regards to the new canyon clip, not only is it a stunning piece of work but it totally redefines the level of craftsmanship one generally expects from a fan edit. I would like to add my .02 to the discussion by saying that I prefer the first clip Ady did. In the second one the TIEs hit each other and deflect into the canyon walls too quickly. It looks "wrong," which I believe was Ady's point.

I also agree with Darth Venom that the camera shake is perhaps a bit amateurish. Is it possible to lessen the shake without scrapping it completely?

As far as the debate that pops up from time to time about space and the reality of physics, I think this should be tabled forever. We cannot on one hand accept that people possess magic powers (the Force) while on the other hand demanding that every other element of the movie conform to scientific principles.

Anyway, just like everyone else here I can't wait to see ESB:R whan it is complete, AND start posting in the ROTJ:R thread